At this point, a standard Hollywood movie would give us a clear villain. Prisoners gives us a mirror.
Unlike modern mysteries that rely on shocking, unearned twists, Prisoners earns every reveal. The clues are there from the opening shot—a hunted deer in the woods—if you know where to look. Jake Gyllenhaal’s Detective Loki is the perfect antidote to Keller’s chaos. With his manicured mustache, obsessive tics, and a torso covered in faded tattoos, Loki is a man running from his own past. Where Keller acts on emotion, Loki acts on gut instinct wrapped in procedure. prisoners -2013-
When Keller kidnaps Alex and begins torturing him for answers, the audience is trapped in a brutal ethical dilemma. We understand Keller’s rage—Jackman’s performance is a primal scream of helplessness—but we also recoil at the graphic violence. We want the girls home, but at what cost to Keller’s soul? Villeneuve doesn’t let us off the hook. He asks: Are we capable of becoming monsters in the name of love? And more terrifyingly, would we be proud of that transformation? The film’s title is a double entendre. Yes, there are literal prisoners (a kidnapped boy in a basement, a tortured man in a shower). But we are all prisoners of the narrative. Screenwriter Aaron Guzikowski constructs a labyrinth that twists with deceptive elegance. At this point, a standard Hollywood movie would
There are thrillers that entertain you for a weekend, and then there are films that burrow under your skin and take up permanent residence. Denis Villeneuve’s Prisoners (2013) is firmly in the latter category. The clues are there from the opening shot—a